Academy for CoachesCreate a Life You Love
All articlesCoaching Fundamentals

What Is Mentor Coaching and Why It Matters

August 31, 20266 min readBy Academy for Coaches

If you've been researching coach training, you've probably seen the term 'mentor coaching' — and you may have wondered what it actually is, and why it matters so much. It's one of the most valuable parts of developing as a coach, and also one of the most misunderstood. Here's a clear explanation.

What is mentor coaching?

Mentor coaching is a process where an experienced, credentialed coach observes your coaching and gives you feedback to help you develop your skill. Unlike regular coaching — where the client's agenda leads — in mentor coaching, you are the client. The focus is on your coaching: how you listen, what you ask, how you facilitate, and where you can grow.

It's not mentoring in the casual sense (someone sharing advice from their experience). It's a structured form of professional development specifically for coaches, recognised by the ICF as part of credentialing.

How mentor coaching works

In a typical mentor coaching engagement, you coach a real or practice client while the mentor coach observes. Afterward, the mentor gives you specific, evidence-based feedback — pointing to particular moments, particular competencies, and particular opportunities to develop. The feedback is about your actual coaching, not about theory.

This is the key difference from simply studying coaching: you get feedback on the real thing. You see where you're strong, where you default to advice, where you missed an opening, and where your presence carried the session. It's how skill becomes visible — and therefore developable.

Mentor coaching vs coaching vs supervision

These three get confused. In coaching, the client's agenda leads and the focus is their life or work. In mentor coaching, you are the client and the focus is your coaching skill. In supervision, the focus is broader — reflecting on your practice, surfacing patterns, and working through ethical tensions. All three have a place in a coach's ongoing development.

Why it matters for your development

Coaching is a skill, and skills develop through practice plus feedback. Without feedback, you can practise the same habits for years without noticing them — including the ones that limit your impact. Mentor coaching surfaces those habits, in a supportive context, so you can choose what to develop next. It's the fastest path from 'I can coach' to 'I coach well.'

It's also a requirement for ICF credentials. To earn an ACC, you need at least 10 hours of mentor coaching with a qualified mentor. That's not bureaucracy — it's because the ICF recognises that real skill develops through observed practice and feedback, not through content alone.

What to look for in mentor coaching

  • A mentor who holds an ICF credential at or above the level you're pursuing.
  • Feedback based on the ICF core competencies, with specific evidence.
  • A balance of group and individual sessions — group lets you learn from others, individual gives you focused attention.
  • A supportive but honest tone — growth needs both encouragement and truth.

Your next step

If you're choosing a coach training programme, look for one that includes mentor coaching as part of the training — not as an extra you have to find and pay for separately. It's one of the clearest signals that the programme is serious about developing real skill.

Explore the ICF Level 1 Certified Professional Coach programme — mentor coaching is part of the training, included.

Explore Coach Certification

Become a Certified Professional Coach

ICF Level 1 accredited. Twelve months of live training. Three specialty certifications. Everything you need to coach professionally and build a practice of your own.

Explore Coach Certification
Have a question? We're here to help.